Skip to Content

Wiki source code of Federation & Decentralization

Version 1.3 by Robert Schaub on 2026/01/20 20:26
Show last authors
1 = Federation & Decentralization =
2
3 **Status**: 🔮 **Planned for V2.0+** (not in V1.0 scope)
4 FactHarbor is designed to eventually support federation, but this feature is **deferred until core product is proven and user demand exists**.
5
6 == V1.0 Scope (Current) ==
7
8 **Single-node deployment**:
9
10 * Full-featured standalone instance
11 * Read replicas for scaling if needed
12 * All features available without federation
13 * Focus on core product quality
14 **Why defer federation**:
15 * Adds massive complexity (sync, conflicts, identity, governance)
16 * Not needed for first 10,000 users
17 * Core product must be proven first
18 * Build when users explicitly request it
19
20 == V2.0+ Federation (Future Vision) ==
21
22 **Implement federation when**:
23
24 * ✅ 10,000+ users on single node
25 * ✅ Users explicitly request decentralization
26 * ✅ Core product is stable and mature
27 * ✅ Geographic distribution becomes necessary
28
29 === Federation Features (Future) ===
30
31 **Independent FactHarbor Instances**:
32
33 * Each node operates autonomously
34 * Local governance and moderation
35 * Regional data sovereignty
36 * Domain specialization possible
37 **Claim Synchronization**:
38 * Claims propagate between trusted nodes
39 * Conflict resolution protocols
40 * Distributed consensus on verdicts
41 * Maintain source attribution
42 **Federated Identity**:
43 * Users recognized across nodes
44 * Reputation portable (with consent)
45 * Single sign-on capabilities
46 * Privacy-preserving authentication
47 **Decentralized Governance**:
48 * Each node sets own policies
49 * Collaborative standards development
50 * Inter-node arbitration for disputes
51 * Federation-level oversight (optional)
52
53 === Technical Architecture (Future) ===
54
55 **Sync Protocol**:
56
57 * ActivityPub-inspired messaging
58 * Claim deltas and updates
59 * Source verification across nodes
60 * Bandwidth-efficient synchronization
61 **Identity Management**:
62 * Decentralized identifiers (DIDs)
63 * Verifiable credentials
64 * Public key infrastructure
65 * Privacy-preserving authentication
66 **Data Sovereignty**:
67 * Each node controls own data
68 * Cross-node queries (opt-in)
69 * GDPR compliance per jurisdiction
70 * Right to be forgotten respected
71
72 === Benefits of Federation (Future) ===
73
74 **Resilience**:
75
76 * No single point of failure
77 * Censorship resistance
78 * Geographic redundancy
79 * Community ownership
80 **Autonomy**:
81 * Local governance
82 * Regional moderation policies
83 * Cultural sensitivity
84 * Domain specialization
85 **Scalability**:
86 * Horizontal growth through new nodes
87 * Regional distribution reduces latency
88 * Load distribution across federation
89 * Independent scaling per node
90 **Trust**:
91 * Decentralized verification
92 * Multiple independent sources
93 * Transparent provenance
94 * Community validation
95
96 === Challenges to Address (Future) ===
97
98 **Technical Complexity**:
99
100 * Synchronization protocols
101 * Conflict resolution
102 * Network reliability
103 * Performance at scale
104 **Governance Complexity**:
105 * Inter-node standards
106 * Dispute resolution
107 * Quality consistency
108 * Abuse handling
109 **User Experience**:
110 * Node discovery
111 * Identity management
112 * Seamless cross-node interaction
113 * Performance transparency
114
115 == Why Not V1.0? ==
116
117 **Reality check**:
118
119 * Most successful platforms start centralized (Wikipedia, Reddit, GitHub)
120 * Federation can be added later (see: Mastodon, Matrix)
121 * Core product quality matters more than architecture philosophy
122 * Users don't care about federation until they need it
123 **Build federation when**:
124 * Users say "I want to run my own instance"
125 * Censorship becomes a real problem
126 * Geographic distribution is required
127 * Community governance demands it
128 Until then: **Focus on making the core product excellent** 🎯
129
130 == Related Pages ==
131
132 * [[Architecture>>Archive.FactHarbor.Specification.Architecture.WebHome]] - Current V1.0 architecture
133 * [[Design Decisions>>FactHarbor.Specification.Design-Decisions]] - Why we defer complexity
134 * [[When to Add Complexity>>FactHarbor.Specification.When-to-Add-Complexity]] - Federation triggers
135
136 == Historical Note ==
137
138 Previous versions (V0.9.50-0.9.58) included detailed federation specifications. These have been moved to future vision documents. The federation architecture is well-designed and ready to implement when the time comes—we're just not building it in V1.0.
139 **See**: `/future-vision/federation-architecture.md` for complete technical specifications (when implemented).