Changes for page POC Summary (POC1 & POC2)

Summary

• Page properties (1 modified, 0 added, 0 removed)

Details

Page properties

Content

...	...	@@ -1,13 +1,14 @@
1		-= FactHarbor - Complete Analysis Summary
	1	+# FactHarbor - Complete Analysis Summary
2	2	**Consolidated Document - No Timelines**
3	3	**Date:** December 19, 2025
4	4
5		-== 1. POC Specification - DEFINITIVE
6	6
7		-=== POC Goal
	6	+## 1. POC Specification - DEFINITIVE
	7	+
	8	+### POC Goal
8	8	Prove that AI can extract claims and determine verdicts automatically without human intervention.
9	9
10		-=== POC Output (4 Components Only)
	11	+### POC Output (4 Components Only)
11	11
12	12	**1. ANALYSIS SUMMARY**
13	13	- 3-5 sentences
...	...	@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@
29	29
30	30	**Total output: ~200-300 words**
31	31
32		-=== What's NOT in POC
	33	+### What's NOT in POC
33	33
34	34	❌ Scenarios (multiple interpretations)
35	35	❌ Evidence display (supporting/opposing lists)
...	...	@@ -41,13 +41,13 @@
41	41	❌ Export, sharing features
42	42	❌ Any other features
43	43
44		-=== Critical Requirement
	45	+### Critical Requirement
45	45
46	46	**FULLY AUTOMATED - NO MANUAL EDITING**
47	47
48	48	This is non-negotiable. POC tests whether AI can do this without human intervention.
49	49
50		-=== POC Success Criteria
	51	+### POC Success Criteria
51	51
52	52	**Passes if:**
53	53	- ✅ AI extracts 3-5 factual claims automatically
...	...	@@ -62,7 +62,7 @@
62	62	- ❌ Requires manual editing for most analyses (> 50%)
63	63	- ❌ Team loses confidence in approach
64	64
65		-=== POC Architecture
	66	+### POC Architecture
66	66
67	67	**Frontend:** Simple input form + results display
68	68	**Backend:** Single API call to Claude (Sonnet 4.5)
...	...	@@ -69,35 +69,175 @@
69	69	**Processing:** One prompt generates complete analysis
70	70	**Database:** None required (stateless)
71	71
72		-=== POC Philosophy
	73	+### POC Philosophy
73	73
74	74	> "Build less, learn more, decide faster. Test the hardest part first."
75	75
76	76
	78	+## 2. Gap Analysis - Strategic Framework
77	77
78		-=== Context-Aware Analysis (Experimental POC1 Feature) ===
	80	+### Framework Definition
79	79
80		-**Problem:** Article credibility ≠ simple average of claim verdicts
	82	+**Importance = f(risk, impact, strategy)**
	83	+- Risk: What breaks if we don't have this?
	84	+- Impact: How many users? How severe?
	85	+- Strategy: Does it advance FactHarbor's mission?
81	81
82		-**Example:** Article with accurate facts (coffee has antioxidants, antioxidants fight cancer) but false conclusion (therefore coffee cures cancer) would score as "mostly accurate" with simple averaging, but is actually MISLEADING.
	87	+**Urgency = f(fail fast and learn, legal, promises made)**
	88	+- Fail fast: Do we need to test assumptions?
	89	+- Legal: External requirements/deadlines?
	90	+- Promises: Commitments to stakeholders?
83	83
84		-**Solution (POC1 Test):** Approach 1 - Single-Pass Holistic Analysis
85		-* Enhanced AI prompt to evaluate logical structure
86		-* AI identifies main argument and assesses if it follows from evidence
87		-* Article verdict may differ from claim average
88		-* Zero additional cost, no architecture changes
	92	+### 18 Gaps Identified
89	89
90		-**Testing:**
91		-* 30-article test set
92		-* Success: ≥70% accuracy detecting misleading articles
93		-* Marked as experimental
	94	+**Category 1: Accessibility & Inclusivity**
	95	+1. WCAG 2.1 Compliance
	96	+2. Multilingual Support
94	94
95		-**See:** [[Article Verdict Problem>>Test.FactHarbor.Specification.POC.Article-Verdict-Problem]] for full analysis and solution approaches.
	98	+**Category 2: Platform Integration**
	99	+3. Browser Extensions
	100	+4. Embeddable Widgets
	101	+5. ClaimReview Schema
96	96
97		-== 2. Key Strategic Recommendations
	103	+**Category 3: Media Verification**
	104	+6. Image/Video/Audio Verification
98	98
99		-=== Immediate Actions
	106	+**Category 4: Mobile & Offline**
	107	+7. Mobile Apps / PWA
	108	+8. Offline Access
100	100
	110	+**Category 5: Education & Media Literacy**
	111	+9. Educational Resources
	112	+10. Media Literacy Integration
	113	+
	114	+**Category 6: Collaboration & Community**
	115	+11. Professional Collaboration Tools
	116	+12. Community Discussion
	117	+
	118	+**Category 7: Export & Sharing**
	119	+13. Export Capabilities (PDF, CSV)
	120	+14. Social Sharing Optimization
	121	+
	122	+**Category 8: Advanced Features**
	123	+15. User Analytics
	124	+16. Personalization
	125	+17. Media Archiving
	126	+18. Advanced Search
	127	+
	128	+### Importance/Urgency Analysis
	129	+
	130	+**VERY HIGH Importance + HIGH Urgency:**
	131	+1. **Accessibility (WCAG)**
	132	+ - Risk: Legal liability, 15-20% users excluded
	133	+ - Urgency: European Accessibility Act (June 28, 2025)
	134	+ - Action: Must be built from start (retrofitting 100x more expensive)
	135	+
	136	+2. **Educational Resources**
	137	+ - Risk: Platform fails if users can't understand
	138	+ - Urgency: Required for any adoption
	139	+ - Action: Basic onboarding essential
	140	+
	141	+**HIGH Importance + MEDIUM Urgency:**
	142	+3. **Browser Extensions** - Standard user expectation, test demand first
	143	+4. **Media Verification** - Cannot address visual misinformation without it
	144	+5. **Multilingual** - Global mission requires it, plan early
	145	+
	146	+**HIGH Importance + LOW Urgency:**
	147	+6. **Mobile Apps** - 90%+ users on mobile, but web-first viable
	148	+7. **ClaimReview Schema** - SEO/discoverability, can add anytime
	149	+
	150	+
	151	+## 1.7 POC Alignment with Full Specification
	152	+
	153	+### POC Intentional Simplifications
	154	+
	155	+**POC1 tests core AI capability, not full architecture:**
	156	+
	157	+**What POC Tests:**
	158	+- Can AI extract claims from articles?
	159	+- Can AI evaluate claims with reasonable verdicts?
	160	+- Is fully automated approach viable?
	161	+- Is output comprehensible to users?
	162	+
	163	+**What POC Excludes (Intentionally):**
	164	+- ❌ Scenarios (deferred to POC2 - open architectural questions remain)
	165	+- ❌ Evidence display (deferred to POC2)
	166	+- ❌ Multi-component AKEL pipeline (simplified to single API call)
	167	+- ❌ Quality gate infrastructure (simplified basic checks)
	168	+- ❌ Production data model (stateless POC)
	169	+- ❌ Review workflow system (no review queue)
	170	+
	171	+**Why Simplified:**
	172	+- Fail fast: Test hardest part first (AI capability)
	173	+- Learn before building: POC1 informs architecture decisions
	174	+- Iterative: Add complexity based on POC1 learnings
	175	+- Risk management: Prove concept before major investment
	176	+
	177	+### Full System Architecture (Future)
	178	+
	179	+**Workflow:**
	180	+{{code}}
	181	+Claims → Scenarios → Evidence → Verdicts
	182	+{{/code}}
	183	+
	184	+**AKEL Components:**
	185	+- Orchestrator
	186	+- Claim Extractor & Classifier
	187	+- Scenario Generator
	188	+- Evidence Summarizer
	189	+- Contradiction Detector
	190	+- Quality Gate Validator
	191	+- Audit Sampling Scheduler
	192	+
	193	+**Publication Modes:**
	194	+- Mode 1: Draft-Only
	195	+- Mode 2: AI-Generated (POC uses this)
	196	+- Mode 3: AKEL-Generated (Human-Reviewed)
	197	+
	198	+### POC vs. Full System Summary
	199	+
	200	+|=Aspect|=POC1|=Full System
	201	+|Scenarios|None (deferred to POC2)|Core component with versioning
	202	+|Workflow|3 steps (input/process/output)|6 phases with quality gates
	203	+|AKEL|Single API call|Multi-component orchestrated pipeline
	204	+|Data|Stateless (no DB)|PostgreSQL + Redis + S3
	205	+|Publication|Mode 2 only|Modes 1/2/3 with risk-based routing
	206	+|Quality Gates|4 simplified checks|Full validation infrastructure
	207	+
	208	+### Gap Between POC and Beta
	209	+
	210	+**Significant architectural expansion needed:**
	211	+1. Scenario generation component design and implementation
	212	+2. Evidence Model full structure
	213	+3. Multi-phase workflow with gates
	214	+4. Component-based AKEL architecture
	215	+5. Production data model and storage
	216	+6. Review workflow and audit systems
	217	+
	218	+**POC proves concept. Beta builds product.**
	219	+
	220	+
	221	+**MEDIUM Importance + LOW Urgency:**
	222	+8-14. All other features - valuable but not urgent
	223	+
	224	+**Strategic Decisions Needed:**
	225	+- Community discussion: Allow or stay evidence-focused?
	226	+- Personalization: How much without filter bubbles?
	227	+- Media verification: Partner with existing tools or build?
	228	+
	229	+### Key Insight: Milestones Change Priorities
	230	+
	231	+**POC:** Only educational resources urgent (basic explainer)
	232	+**Beta:** Accessibility becomes urgent (test with diverse users)
	233	+**Release:** Legal requirements become critical (WCAG, GDPR)
	234	+
	235	+**Importance/urgency are contextual, not absolute.**
	236	+
	237	+
	238	+## 3. Key Strategic Recommendations
	239	+
	240	+### Immediate Actions
	241	+
101	101	**For POC:**
102	102	1. Focus on core functionality only (claims + verdicts)
103	103	2. Create basic explainer (1 page)
...	...	@@ -110,7 +110,7 @@
110	110	3. Research media verification options (partner vs build)
111	111	4. Evaluate browser extension approach
112	112
113		-=== Testing Strategy
	254	+### Testing Strategy
114	114
115	115	**POC Tests:** Can AI do this without humans?
116	116	**Beta Tests:** What do users need? What works? What doesn't?
...	...	@@ -118,7 +118,7 @@
118	118
119	119	**Key Principle:** Test assumptions before building features.
120	120
121		-=== Build Sequence (Priority Order)
	262	+### Build Sequence (Importance Order)
122	122
123	123	**Must Build:**
124	124	1. Core analysis (claims + verdicts) ← POC
...	...	@@ -136,51 +136,53 @@
136	136	9. Export features ← Based on user requests
137	137	10. Everything else ← Based on validation
138	138
139		-=== Decision Framework
	280	+### Decision Framework
140	140
141	141	**For each feature, ask:**
142	142	1. **Importance:** Risk + Impact + Strategy alignment?
143	143	2. **Urgency:** Fail fast + Legal + Promises?
144	144	3. **Validation:** Do we know users want this?
145		-4. **Priority:** When should we build it?
	286	+4. **Importance:** When should we build it?
146	146
147	147	**Don't build anything without answering these questions.**
148	148
149		-== 4. Critical Principles
150	150
151		-=== Automation First
	291	+## 4. Critical Principles
	292	+
	293	+### Automation First
152	152	- AI makes content decisions
153	153	- Humans improve algorithms
154	154	- Scale through code, not people
155	155
156		-=== Fail Fast
	298	+### Fail Fast
157	157	- Test assumptions quickly
158	158	- Don't build unvalidated features
159	159	- Accept that experiments may fail
160	160	- Learn from failures
161	161
162		-=== Evidence Over Authority
	304	+### Evidence Over Authority
163	163	- Transparent reasoning visible
164	164	- No single "true/false" verdicts
165	165	- Multiple scenarios shown
166	166	- Assumptions made explicit
167	167
168		-=== User Focus
	310	+### User Focus
169	169	- Serve users' needs first
170	170	- Build what's actually useful
171	171	- Don't build what's just "cool"
172	172	- Measure and iterate
173	173
174		-=== Honest Assessment
	316	+### Honest Assessment
175	175	- Don't cherry-pick examples
176	176	- Document failures openly
177	177	- Accept limitations
178	178	- No overpromising
179	179
180		-== 5. POC Decision Gate
181	181
182		-=== After POC, Choose:
	323	+## 5. POC Decision Gate
183	183
	325	+### After POC, Choose:
	326	+
184	184	**GO (Proceed to Beta):**
185	185	- AI quality ≥70% without editing
186	186	- Approach validated
...	...	@@ -199,37 +199,39 @@
199	199	- Addressable with better prompts
200	200	- Test again after changes
201	201
202		-== 6. Key Risks & Mitigations
203	203
204		-=== Risk 1: AI Quality Not Good Enough
	346	+## 6. Key Risks & Mitigations
	347	+
	348	+### Risk 1: AI Quality Not Good Enough
205	205	**Mitigation:** Extensive prompt testing, use best models
206	206	**Acceptance:** POC might fail - that's what testing reveals
207	207
208		-=== Risk 2: Users Don't Understand Output
	352	+### Risk 2: Users Don't Understand Output
209	209	**Mitigation:** Create clear explainer, test with real users
210	210	**Acceptance:** Iterate on explanation until comprehensible
211	211
212		-=== Risk 3: Approach Doesn't Scale
	356	+### Risk 3: Approach Doesn't Scale
213	213	**Mitigation:** Start simple, add complexity only when proven
214	214	**Acceptance:** POC proves concept, beta proves scale
215	215
216		-=== Risk 4: Legal/Compliance Issues
	360	+### Risk 4: Legal/Compliance Issues
217	217	**Mitigation:** Plan accessibility early, consult legal experts
218	218	**Acceptance:** Can't launch publicly without compliance
219	219
220		-=== Risk 5: Feature Creep
	364	+### Risk 5: Feature Creep
221	221	**Mitigation:** Strict scope discipline, say NO to additions
222	222	**Acceptance:** POC is minimal by design
223	223
224		-== 7. Success Metrics
225	225
226		-=== POC Success
	369	+## 7. Success Metrics
	370	+
	371	+### POC Success
227	227	- AI output quality ≥70%
228	228	- Manual editing needed < 30% of time
229	229	- Team confidence: High
230	230	- Decision: GO to beta
231	231
232		-=== Platform Success (Later)
	377	+### Platform Success (Later)
233	233	- User comprehension ≥80%
234	234	- Return user rate ≥30%
235	235	- Flag rate (user corrections) < 10%
...	...	@@ -236,34 +236,36 @@
236	236	- Processing time < 30 seconds
237	237	- Error rate < 1%
238	238
239		-=== Mission Success (Long-term)
	384	+### Mission Success (Long-term)
240	240	- Users make better-informed decisions
241	241	- Misinformation spread reduced
242	242	- Public discourse improves
243	243	- Trust in evidence increases
244	244
245		-== 8. What Makes FactHarbor Different
246	246
247		-=== Not Traditional Fact-Checking
	391	+## 8. What Makes FactHarbor Different
	392	+
	393	+### Not Traditional Fact-Checking
248	248	- ❌ No simple "true/false" verdicts
249	249	- ✅ Multiple scenarios with context
250	250	- ✅ Transparent reasoning chains
251	251	- ✅ Explicit assumptions shown
252	252
253		-=== Not AI Chatbot
	399	+### Not AI Chatbot
254	254	- ❌ Not conversational
255	255	- ✅ Structured Evidence Models
256	256	- ✅ Reproducible analysis
257	257	- ✅ Verifiable sources
258	258
259		-=== Not Just Automation
	405	+### Not Just Automation
260	260	- ❌ Not replacing human judgment
261	261	- ✅ Augmenting human reasoning
262	262	- ✅ Making process transparent
263	263	- ✅ Enabling informed decisions
264	264
265		-== 9. Core Philosophy
266	266
	412	+## 9. Core Philosophy
	413	+
267	267	**Three Pillars:**
268	268
269	269	**1. Scenarios Over Verdicts**
...	...	@@ -284,28 +284,30 @@
284	284	- Evaluate source quality
285	285	- Avoid cherry-picking
286	286
287		-== 10. Next Actions
288	288
289		-=== Immediate
	435	+## 10. Next Actions
	436	+
	437	+### Immediate
290	290	□ Review this consolidated summary
291	291	□ Confirm POC scope agreement
292	292	□ Make strategic decisions on key questions
293	293	□ Begin POC development
294	294
295		-=== Strategic Planning
	443	+### Strategic Planning
296	296	□ Define accessibility approach
297	297	□ Select initial languages for multilingual
298	298	□ Research media verification partners
299	299	□ Evaluate browser extension frameworks
300	300
301		-=== Continuous
	449	+### Continuous
302	302	□ Test assumptions before building
303	303	□ Measure everything
304	304	□ Learn from failures
305	305	□ Stay focused on mission
306	306
307		-== Summary of Summaries
308	308
	456	+## Summary of Summaries
	457	+
309	309	**POC Goal:** Prove AI can do this automatically
310	310	**POC Scope:** 4 simple components, ~200-300 words
311	311	**POC Critical:** Fully automated, no manual editing
...	...	@@ -318,8 +318,9 @@
318	318	**Strategy:** Test first, build second. Fail fast. Stay focused.
319	319	**Philosophy:** Scenarios, transparency, evidence. No false certainty.
320	320
321		-== Document Status
322	322
	471	+## Document Status
	472	+
323	323	**This document supersedes all previous analysis documents.**
324	324
325	325	All gap analysis, POC specifications, and strategic frameworks are consolidated here without timeline references.
...	...	@@ -331,5 +331,6 @@
331	331
332	332	**Previous documents are archived for reference but this is the authoritative summary.**
333	333
	484	+
334	334	**End of Consolidated Summary**
335	335