Skip to Content

Changes for page Workflows

Last modified by Robert Schaub on 2025/12/24 20:34
From version 2.1
edited by Robert Schaub
on 2025/12/11 20:16
Change comment: Imported from XAR
To version 4.1
edited by Robert Schaub
on 2025/12/12 15:41
Change comment: Imported from XAR

Summary

Details

Page properties
Content
... ... @@ -8,7 +8,6 @@
8 8  * Participants
9 9  * Steps
10 10  * Automation vs. manual work
11 -* (Wherever applicable) linear ASCII flow: a → b → c → d
12 12  
13 13  Workflows included:
14 14  
... ... @@ -37,39 +37,39 @@
37 37  
38 38  === Steps ===
39 39  
40 -**1. Ingestion**
39 +1. **Ingestion**
41 41  * User submits text, URL, transcript, or multi-claim content
42 42  * AKEL extracts one or multiple claims
43 43  
44 -**2. Normalization**
43 +1. **Normalization**
45 45  * Standardizes wording
46 46  * Reduces ambiguity
47 47  * Flags implicit assumptions
48 48  
49 -**3. Classification (AKEL draft → Reviewer confirm)**
48 +1. **Classification (AKEL draft → Reviewer confirm)**
50 50  * ClaimType
51 51  * Domain
52 52  * Evaluability
53 53  * SafetyCategory
54 54  
55 -**4. Duplicate & Similarity Detection**
54 +1. **Duplicate & Similarity Detection**
56 56  * Embeddings created
57 57  * Similar claims found
58 58  * Reviewer merges, splits, or confirms uniqueness
59 59  
60 -**5. Version Creation**
59 +1. **Version Creation**
61 61  * New ClaimVersion stored
62 62  * Every edit creates a new immutable version
63 63  
64 -**6. Cluster Assignment**
63 +1. **Cluster Assignment**
65 65  * AKEL proposes cluster membership
66 66  * Reviewer confirms
67 67  
68 -**7. Scenario Linking (optional)**
67 +1. **Scenario Linking (optional)**
69 69  * Existing scenarios connected
70 70  * AKEL may propose new drafts
71 71  
72 -**8. Publication**
71 +1. **Publication**
73 73  * Claim becomes active and visible
74 74  
75 75  **Flow:**
... ... @@ -90,10 +90,10 @@
90 90  
91 91  === Steps ===
92 92  
93 -**1. Scenario Proposal**
92 +1. **Scenario Proposal**
94 94  * Drafted by contributor or generated by AKEL
95 95  
96 -**2. Completion of Required Fields**
95 +1. **Completion of Required Fields**
97 97  Must include:
98 98  * Definitions
99 99  * Assumptions
... ... @@ -102,22 +102,22 @@
102 102  * SafetyClass
103 103  * VersionMetadata
104 104  
105 -**3. Safety Interception (AKEL)**
104 +1. **Safety Interception (AKEL)**
106 106  Flags:
107 107  * non-falsifiable structures
108 108  * pseudoscientific assumptions
109 109  * unsafe contexts
110 110  
111 -**4. Redundancy & Conflict Check**
110 +1. **Redundancy & Conflict Check**
112 112  * Similar scenarios merged
113 113  * Contradictions flagged
114 114  
115 -**5. Reviewer Validation**
114 +1. **Reviewer Validation**
116 116  Ensures clarity, neutrality, and methodological validity.
117 117  
118 -**6. Expert Approval (mandatory for high-risk domains)**
117 +1. **Expert Approval (mandatory for high-risk domains)**
119 119  
120 -**7. Version Storage**
119 +1. **Version Storage**
121 121  * Each revision = new ScenarioVersion
122 122  
123 123  **Flow:**
... ... @@ -138,10 +138,10 @@
138 138  
139 139  === Steps ===
140 140  
141 -**1. Evidence Submission**
140 +1. **Evidence Submission**
142 142  * File, dataset, URL, or extracted text
143 143  
144 -**2. Metadata Extraction (AKEL)**
143 +1. **Metadata Extraction (AKEL)**
145 145  * EvidenceType
146 146  * Category
147 147  * Provenance
... ... @@ -149,21 +149,21 @@
149 149  * ExtractionMethod
150 150  * ReliabilityHints
151 151  
152 -**3. Relevance Check**
151 +1. **Relevance Check**
153 153  Reviewer verifies which scenarios the evidence applies to.
154 154  
155 -**4. Reliability Assessment**
154 +1. **Reliability Assessment**
156 156  * AKEL proposes reliability
157 157  * Reviewer confirms
158 158  * Expert review for complex papers
159 159  
160 -**5. ScenarioEvidenceLink Creation**
159 +1. **ScenarioEvidenceLink Creation**
161 161  Each link stores:
162 162  * relevance score
163 163  * justification
164 164  * evidence version
165 165  
166 -**6. Versioning**
165 +1. **Versioning**
167 167  * Any update = new EvidenceVersion
168 168  
169 169  **Flow:**
... ... @@ -183,10 +183,10 @@
183 183  
184 184  === Steps ===
185 185  
186 -**1. Evidence Aggregation**
185 +1. **Evidence Aggregation**
187 187  Collect relevant evidence versions.
188 188  
189 -**2. Draft Verdict Generation (AKEL)**
188 +1. **Draft Verdict Generation (AKEL)**
190 190  Outputs:
191 191  * likelihood range
192 192  * uncertainty factors
... ... @@ -193,13 +193,13 @@
193 193  * conflict detection
194 194  * sensitivity analysis
195 195  
196 -**3. Reasoning Draft**
195 +1. **Reasoning Draft**
197 197  Structured explanation chain generated by AKEL.
198 198  
199 -**4. Reviewer Validation**
198 +1. **Reviewer Validation**
200 200  Ensures logic, evidence fit, no hallucinations.
201 201  
202 -**5. Expert Review**
201 +1. **Expert Review**
203 203  Required for:
204 204  * medicine
205 205  * psychology
... ... @@ -207,7 +207,7 @@
207 207  * political misinformation
208 208  * controversial or risky domains
209 209  
210 -**6. Verdict Storage**
209 +1. **Verdict Storage**
211 211  * Every update creates a new VerdictVersion
212 212  
213 213  **Flow:**
... ... @@ -230,24 +230,24 @@
230 230  
231 231  === Steps ===
232 232  
233 -**1. Trigger Detection**
232 +1. **Trigger Detection**
234 234  Re-evaluation engine receives event.
235 235  
236 -**2. Impact Analysis**
235 +1. **Impact Analysis**
237 237  Find affected:
238 238  * scenarios
239 239  * evidence links
240 240  * verdicts
241 241  
242 -**3. AKEL Draft Re-calculation**
241 +1. **AKEL Draft Re-calculation**
243 243  New:
244 244  * likelihood
245 245  * reasoning
246 246  * uncertainty
247 247  
248 -**4. Reviewer Validation**
249 -**5. Expert Review** (high-risk)
250 -**6. Version Storage**
247 +1. **Reviewer Validation**
248 +1. **Expert Review** (high-risk)
249 +1. **Version Storage**
251 251  
252 252  **Flow:**
253 253  Trigger → Analyze → Recompute → Review → Expert → Version
... ... @@ -279,18 +279,18 @@
279 279  
280 280  === Steps ===
281 281  
282 -**1. Submission**
281 +1. **Submission**
283 283  Claim / scenario / evidence / verdict.
284 284  
285 -**2. Auto-check (AKEL)**
284 +1. **Auto-check (AKEL)**
286 286  Flags unsafe content, contradictions, format issues.
287 287  
288 -**3. Reviewer Validation**
287 +1. **Reviewer Validation**
289 289  
290 -**4. Expert Validation**
289 +1. **Expert Validation**
291 291  Required for sensitive domains.
292 292  
293 -**5. Moderator Oversight**
292 +1. **Moderator Oversight**
294 294  Triggered by suspicious behavior.
295 295  
296 296  **Flow:**