Changes for page Automation Level

Last modified by Robert Schaub on 2025/12/24 20:33

From version 1.1
edited by Robert Schaub
on 2025/12/11 21:35
Change comment: Imported from XAR
To version 2.1
edited by Robert Schaub
on 2025/12/14 18:59
Change comment: Imported from XAR

Summary

Details

Page properties
Content
... ... @@ -2,26 +2,118 @@
2 2  
3 3  {{mermaid}}
4 4  graph TD
5 - L0[Level 0: Human-Centric POC
6 -- AI Advisory only
7 -- No auto-publish
8 -- Manual Governance]
5 + L0[Level 0: AI-Publication POC
6 + - AI-Generated Content Publication
7 + - Quality Gates Active
8 + - Contradiction Search Mandatory
9 + - Risk Tier Classification
10 + - Audit Sampling Started
11 + - Recommendations: 30-50% Tier A, 10-20% B, 5-10% C]
9 9  
10 10   L1[Level 1: Assisted Beta 0
11 -- AI drafts structures
12 -- Human approval per component]
14 + - AI drafts structures + publishes Tier C
15 + - Humans audit samples
16 + - Tier B mostly AI-published
17 + - Tier A requires human review
18 + - Feedback loop active
19 + - Sampling rates adjust based on performance]
13 13  
14 14   L2[Level 2: Structured Release 1.0
15 -- Full scenario scaffolding
16 -- Auto scoring & summaries
17 -- Human governance/override]
22 + - AI produces near-complete outputs
23 + - Most Tier B AI-published
24 + - Tier A human-reviewed for publication
25 + - Mature audit system
26 + - Lower sampling rates as confidence increases]
18 18  
19 - L3[Level 3: Distributed Future
20 -- Cross-node embeddings
21 -- Shared contradictions
22 -- Human approval still required]
23 -
28 + L3[Level 3: Distributed Intelligence Future
29 + - Federated contradiction detection
30 + - Cross-node audit sharing
31 + - Advanced bubble detection
32 + - Tier A still human-reviewed
33 + - Strategic audits only]
34 +
24 24   L0 --> L1
25 25   L1 --> L2
26 26   L2 --> L3
38 +
39 + subgraph "Constant Across All Levels"
40 + HumanAuth[Humans retain final authority
41 + Quality gates mandatory
42 + Tier A requires human review for Mode 3
43 + Audit system active
44 + All numbers are recommendations]
45 + end
46 +
47 + classDef current fill:#e3f2fd,stroke:#1976d2,stroke-width:3px
48 + classDef future fill:#f3e5f5,stroke:#7b1fa2,stroke-width:2px
49 +
50 + class L0 current
51 + class L3 future
27 27  {{/mermaid}}
53 +
54 +== Evolution of Automation ==
55 +
56 +=== Level 0 (POC) - Current ===
57 +**Philosophy**: Demonstrate AI-generated publication with quality oversight
58 +
59 +**Key Feature**: POC explicitly publishes AI-generated content (Mode 2), demonstrating scalable publication model with quality gates.
60 +
61 +**Automation**:
62 +* Risk tier classification
63 +* Quality gates enforcement
64 +* Contradiction search
65 +* AI-draft publication (Tier C, some Tier B)
66 +
67 +**Human Role**:
68 +* Tier A review
69 +* Audit sampling (recommendations: 30-50% A, 10-20% B, 5-10% C)
70 +* Quality standard refinement
71 +
72 +=== Level 1 (Beta 0) ===
73 +**Philosophy**: Scale AI publication while maintaining quality through audits
74 +
75 +**Automation**:
76 +* Expanded AI publication (most Tier B, all Tier C)
77 +* Mature contradiction detection
78 +* Cross-scenario analysis
79 +
80 +**Human Role**:
81 +* Tier A oversight
82 +* Continued audits (rates adjust as confidence increases)
83 +* Expert domain validation
84 +
85 +=== Level 2 (Release 1.0) ===
86 +**Philosophy**: Efficient AI publication with strategic human oversight
87 +
88 +**Automation**:
89 +* Comprehensive AI generation and publication
90 +* Federated knowledge sharing
91 +* Advanced anomaly detection
92 +
93 +**Human Role**:
94 +* Tier A final approval
95 +* Strategic audits (high-value sampling)
96 +* Policy and ethics decisions
97 +
98 +=== Level 3 (Future) ===
99 +**Philosophy**: Distributed intelligence with human governance
100 +
101 +**Automation**:
102 +* Cross-node contradiction detection
103 +* Shared audit learnings
104 +* Sophisticated bubble detection
105 +
106 +**Human Role**:
107 +* Governance
108 +* Ethical oversight
109 +* Tier A authority
110 +* Conflict resolution
111 +
112 +== Important Note ==
113 +
114 +All numeric values (sampling rates, percentages) are **recommendations**, not fixed rules. Actual rates determined by:
115 +* Audit performance metrics
116 +* Domain-specific requirements
117 +* Community consensus
118 +* Governing Team decisions
119 +